A new phase in Russia-Ukraine talks
ICYMI, there’s been quite a flurry of diplomacy over the Russo-Ukrainian war over the past few days. And just like those Magic Eye images, the full 3D picture doesn’t quite emerge until you squint your eyes and step back.
Let’s get into it.
Last week, the US, Ukraine, and Russia held their first trilateral in-person talks since February, amid a renewed push for peace from the Trump administration.
Emissaries were sent to Abu Dhabi for two days of negotiations. Then, one day later, US Special Envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff hopped on a plane to Moscow, where they met with Russian President Vladimir Putin for follow-up talks and then had a quick layover in Dublin, where they caught up with Ukraine’s leader Zelensky.
There are a few things worth noting:
The US has a new NATO proposal
Last Friday, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky told journalists US negotiators had advanced a new proposal: would Kyiv cede the entirety of the Donbas region, including territory currently still held by Ukraine, in exchange for NATO membership?
This is a whole new line of negotiation altogether, with Zelensky confirming that “it was the first time this had been raised”.
The full contours of the proposal aren’t yet clear: the Ukrainian President appeared somewhat sceptical but did not dismiss the possibility, adding that if Europe and the US offered Ukraine full security guarantees, no limits on Ukraine’s armed forces, and aid to rebuild the country, he would be willing to put the question to a national vote.
It’s an interesting proposition from US negotiators on several fronts.
First, recall that DC had previously dismissed the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO. Considering that President Trump’s attitude towards Ukraine hasn’t magically softened overnight, we’re left wondering why the US is dangling this offer now.
Secondly, Russia seems unlikely to accept it. Putin has blamed NATO expansion as a key trigger for his invasion, arguing the alliance represents an imminent threat to Russian security. Agreeing to such terms would leave Putin to return home after four years of brutal trench warfare with a Donbas-shaped trophy and little else.
Even if full NATO membership isn’t on the cards, Zelensky made clear he’d accept nothing less than an Article-5-style security guarantee backed by NATO members and the European Union. But that wouldn’t be acceptable to Moscow, which insists on limits on Ukraine’s army, and a ban on foreign troops on Ukrainian soil.
So again, why this offer and why now? It could be a way to probe and test Ukraine’s position on territorial concessions. Or it could be an attempt by Zelensky to pressure the US to commit to the hypothetical security guarantees by going public with the proposal, while also measuring public reaction.
And on the topic of probing opposition stances…
Moscow’s “new security architecture” for Europe
Listen, we’re fans of Russian architecture: from the Byzantine revival to the more avant-garde Modernist style, there’s something for everyone. But when we hear the Kremlin starts talking about a “new European security architecture”, that’s when our spidey-senses go off.
During last week’s talks, Russia pushed to include Europe’s entire security network as part of its negotiations to end the war, arguing that a system of clearly-defined regional influence spheres was needed to address Russia’s concerns.
According to documents seen by the New York Times, the Russian delegation presented an opening position including:
A withdrawal of NATO troops and bases to the alliance’s 1997 borders, before its eastward expansion,
An agreement from France and the UK to not expand their nuclear umbrella to other European nations, and
Ukraine’s exclusion from the EU’s mutual defence clause in the event of its joining.
These might be just maximalist positions in an unofficial ‘non-paper’ used to make the rest of Russia’s demands appear more reasonable. But the US President has now also hinted that he’d be happy to discuss Europe’s security as part of a deal with Russia, stating: “There’s gonna be an agreement, it’s gonna be a big agreement, and it’s gonna involve more than Ukraine”, adding, “I could even say it’s going to involve all of Europe”.
Regardless of where the negotiations eventually land, Putin seems to be succeeding in shifting the conversation from ‘how to end the Russo-Ukraine war’ into broader discussions about the future of Europe’s security architecture.
And in engaging the US on this latter point, he’s getting a three-for-one before even making any concessions, with DC tacitly agreeing to his previous point about NATO expansion being a trigger for the war, recognition of Russia as a great power, and agreement that Europe is firmly within Russia’s sphere of influence.
All this talk has already sent Europe into a tailspin, with French President Emmanuel Macron rejecting the notion that Moscow would have any say in the bloc’s future security.
Speaking of Europe…
Europe’s ‘Dream Team’
The EU has announced that it has finally selected a committee to represent it at future peace negotiations. The team will include the UK, France, Germany, Italy, and Poland as well as representatives from EU institutions.
It’s as good a time as any for the bloc to find common ground, considering that Russia announced that it would be open to Europe joining peace talks last Friday.
One upside to this development is that Europe will now fulfil its long-standing demand to be included at the negotiating table. Ukraine will thus also get a friendlier voice in the room.
As always, the question is, why now? Well, Europe’s entry into the negotiations will also allow Russia to further press its points on the need for a “new European security architecture” and possibly bog down the negotiations in broader points that have little to do with the immediate conflict.
Finally, last week’s trilateral talks also yielded an agreement to pursue a large-scale prisoner exchange, with Kushner describing it as possibly the war’s largest. With everything else going on right now, we’ll take all the good news we can get.
Sound even smarter:
Estonia announced Sunday it would close its border with Russia starting 1 December over an alleged sabotage attempt against defence company Threod Systems.
Members-only analysis
Intrigue’s Take
Get full access to Jeremy, John and Helen’s unvarnished takes on the world and what it means for you.

