The Hague’s historic ruling
The UN's top court (the ICJ) just delivered its historic verdict in The Gambia vs Myanmar case after seven years of courtroom debate.
But first... The Gambia you say? Mainland Africa's smallest nation? Smaller than Connecticut? 11,500km (7,150mi) away? But suing Myanmar?
Yes, under the 1948 Genocide Convention, any signatory state can sue another. But for The Gambia, a few things aligned:
its then-justice minister (Tambadou) was a former Rwanda genocide prosecutor who had visited Rohingya refugees first-hand
The Gambia is also (like the Rohingya) overwhelmingly Muslim, and
the 57-member OIC bloc of Muslim-majority countries footed the legal bills.
It's also easier for a distant, unrelated player to sue Myanmar, rather than (say) an immediate neighbour like Bangladesh that's hosting a million Rohingya refugees and could face direct regime blowback.
Anyway, capitals the world over are now pondering the resulting 191-page judgement, so here are its five spiciest lines, starting with...
“The Republic of the Union of Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in Northern Rakhine State.”
In a split 9-6 decision, the ICJ has now found a state responsible for genocide for the first time in the court's 80-year history (in 2007 it found Serbia had failed to prevent the Srebrenica genocide).
In this Myanmar case, the ruling covers Myanmar's brutal August 2017 "clearance operations" after armed Rohingya groups attacked security posts.
But even reference to "the Rohingya group" is itself a big legal deal, as Myanmar has long insisted Rohingya are Bengali immigrants rather than a distinct ethnic group. So right there, the court is dismantling one of the regime's main defences: whether the Rohingya are even a "group" for the purposes of the genocide definition.
Then there's (brace yourself)...
“The execution of Rohingya men and boys in some locations, the widespread sexual violence, including gang and mass rape, the targeting of children and babies, the methodical burning of villages and attacks on fleeing civilians are not consistent with an intent to conduct counter-insurgency operations.”
That grim line is not for colour, but to dismantle the regime's next argument that it was simply fighting a legitimate counter-insurgency against armed Rohingya.
But the court even went beyond just dismantling here, instead finding the two angles aren't even mutually exclusive: ie, you can have a legitimate goal (like counter-terrorism) but still be guilty of genocide based on the totality of your conduct.
Speaking of which...
“The fact that members of a protected group could be lawfully targeted or incidentally harmed under international humanitarian law does not exclude the possibility that they may be killed or harmed with genocidal intent.”
That word-salad basically destroys the regime's third main "law of war" argument: ie, there's a separate body of international humanitarian law which looks at how you fight a war, accepting the reality that if you're targeting legitimate combatants, civilian deaths might not only be lawful, but inevitable.
But the court says even if (say) individual airstrikes complied with those rules of war, if they're happening alongside acts like hate speech, starvation, or destroying the conditions a community needs to survive, then they can still constitute genocide.
And that brings us to...
“The estimated 10,000 Rohingya that were killed constituted 1.2 per cent of the targeted population.”
That line dismisses the regime's last main argument (among many, to be clear), that if they truly intended to commit genocide, the death toll would've been way higher.
This point was so contentious, it split the bench, with the six dissenters questioning whether the evidence pointed to genocide rather than forced expulsion.
But the majority concluded that "destroying" a group (per the definition) isn't just about body-count math. Rather, they considered the deaths alongside evidence of 1,834 rapes, birth restrictions, razing 392 villages, and expelling 85%+ of the area’s broader community, finding there was genocidal intent, high mortality or not.
So then let's wrap with...
“The Rohingya certainly, first and foremost, will know that they can't eat a verdict from the ICJ.”
Okay, that wasn't the court, but US rights campaigner Matthew Smith, making the point that even though this ruling is final, binding, and sweeping (pay reparations, facilitate returns, prosecute offenders), the ICJ now has zero real ability to enforce it. Rather, enforcement depends on the UN Security Council, where regime backers like China and Russia have often (though not always) used their vetoes to shield Myanmar.
And even if Myanmar wanted to comply, that's now complicated by the fact that another armed ethnic group (Arakan Army) later cleared the regime out of those Rohingya areas, and still runs the region. The Buddhist Arakan and Muslim Rohingya themselves have a long history of bloodshed, so Arakans won’t roll out the red carpet.
Either way, the regime — still fighting its own brutal civil war with Beijing-Moscow support — has now rejected the ruling as unfair.
So for now, this historic verdict's initial impact might just be diplomatic (slowing the regime's re-entry to the international community) and legal (maybe accelerating the International Criminal Court's separate push to arrest junta chief, Min Aung Hlaing).
Sound even smarter:
Ukraine’s genocide case against Russia is due for verdict around late 2029 or 2030.
The original 1948 treaty defines genocide as “any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: (a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.”
Members-only analysis
Intrigue’s Take
Get full access to Jeremy, John and Helen’s unvarnished takes on the world and what it means for you.

