China-US rivalry looms large at top Asia summit


Briefly: The annual three day Shangri-La Dialogue wrapped up yesterday (Sunday), after bringing together 600 defence and security delegates from 49 countries at the sprawling Shangri-La Hotel in Singapore.

Each year the summit generates seemingly endless headlines, particularly around US-China competition. And this year was no exception. Highlights included:

  • 🇦🇺 Australia’s PM urged China to re-open dialogue with the US
  • 🇺🇸 The US defence secretary rebuked China for not resuming military talks with the US
  • 🇨🇳 China’s defence minister called on the US to decease military deployments near China
  • 🇵🇭 A Philippines coast guard rep said there was a disconnect between China’s pro-dialogue words and its actions in the South China Sea
  • 🇩🇪 Germany’s defence minister announced Germany will send two warships to the Indo-Pacific in 2024 to help maintain regional security
  • 🇮🇩 Indonesia’s defence minister revealed a Russo-Ukraine peace plan focused on demilitarised zones in Ukraine (a proposal quickly dismissed by Ukraine’s defence minister, who said it sounded like a “Russian plan”)

Intrigue’s take: There was plenty of disagreement on display in Singapore over the weekend, yet almost everyone seemed to agree on one thing: US-China conflict would be a disaster not just for the two countries, but the entire world.

And so… given everyone agrees, there should be a path for China and the West to de-escalate. The problem is it’s hard to see one right now:

  • China’s military build-up and increasing assertiveness have spooked capitals all over, and yet
  • When other countries respond with their own military build-up to deter China, Beijing interprets that as aggression, and again expands its military in response

This, dear Intriguer, is a classic security dilemma. And it’s hard to break out of one without dialogue. Hence the many calls for dialogue over the weekend.

Also worth noting:

  • China is set to increase defence spending this year by 7.2% to $220B. US defence spending is up 4.2% this year, hitting $773B.
  • Some two dozen spy chiefs also met on the sidelines of the summit, including intelligence heads from China, the US, India, Europe, and beyond. The tone was reportedly more direct but more collaborative.
Latest Author Articles
Who just leaked US intelligence on Israel?

A couple of highly classified US intelligence documents somehow landed in the media over the weekend, with a pro-Iran site first highlighting them on Friday. What happened? Some of the coverage has breathlessly described the leaked docs as Israel’s “plans” to attack Iran, so you’d be forgiven for thinking maybe they were some kind of Looney Tunes […]

21 October, 2024
Israel kills Hamas leader, Yahya Sinwar

Israel has announced the death of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, the group’s latest overall leader and the architect of the Hamas attacks on Israel last October 7th. The co-founder of the Hamas armed wing, Sinwar spent more than two decades in an Israeli prison for his role in the 1989 kidnapping and murder of two Israeli soldiers and four Palestinians […]

18 October, 2024
UN peacekeepers under pressure in Lebanon

The UN peacekeeping mission in southern Lebanon issued a spicy statement yesterday (Sunday), saying “for the fourth time in as many days, we remind the IDF [Israel Defense Forces] and all actors of their obligations to ensure the safety and security of UN personnel and property and to respect the inviolability of UN premises at all times.“ What happened? […]

14 October, 2024
The Middle East, one year on

It’s now been a year since the Hamas attacks on Israel left 1,200 dead, so let’s take a look at how our world has changed since October 7, through the eyes and words of some of the main protagonists who’ve all made public statements in recent days. Netanyahu made that pledge yesterday (Sunday), and it not only […]

7 October, 2024